Twitter still isn’t Voxpopping; it’s a conversation everyone’s in on

Last week I attended the Media140 conference at the ABC studios in Ultimo. Journalists, bloggers, media nerds, students and politicians (and their ghost Twitter writers) gathered to discuss what appears to be the top two topics the self-obsessed media are focused on right now:  Twitter and “Oh crap, how will I be paid for journalism now?”.

The first entry is all about the darling of the social media circuit: Twitter.

Earlier this year, I said on this blog that I believed that journalists should not be using Twitter as a replacement for vox pops. While I stand by that original assessment, Twitter has really become much more than what I envisioned it to be over the past year. It is less something journalists have a vague curiosity about and more something that many journalists are now participating in. In the past 10 months we’ve seen it play a vital role in the reporting of events such as the Iran election, Michael Jackson’s death, and more locally the dust storm that spread over Sydney. The combination of widespread media coverage, celebrity Tweeters and through the use of hashtags and trending topics, Twitter users are now more aware of how their tweets may be seen and are able to make their tweets easier to find for people following these topics, journalists or not. Tweeters using hashtags are now actively choosing to have this information spread, meaning it has now changed from being a more passive source of information for journalists to one where the journalist is more part of the Twitter community.

We’ve seen mainstream media journalists such as Leigh Sales, Mark Colvin, Annabel Crabb and Caroline Overington all enter the Twitterverse and actively engage with other Twitter users, linking to their content and even tweeting during Question Time. All of whom were present at the Media140 conference on Thursday and at the conference, ABC Managing Director Mark Scott also announced a new set of social media guidelines for all ABC journalists and staff. These guidelines are the first in Australia (that have been published) and make it clear that,  for at least the ABC, it is important to ensure journalists are using social media ethically.

Thankfully, apart from Chris “Five Times” Ulhmann, all of the mainstream media journalists at the conference recognised the value of Twitter as a tool for journalists and none saw it as a fad. All of them believed that the use of Twitter should for sourcing should be treated no differently from how journalists would normally source information, and the same checks must be applied otherwise journalists risk, as Annabel Crabb put it, from having a “Richard Wilkins moment”. Crabb also stated she used Twitter as a means to take notes while sharing the goings-on during Question Time and often pinched the funnier replies she got on Twitter for her column (crediting where possible). Leigh Sales showed us that journalists can be personal and casual on Twitter while still maintaining their brand as a journalist through the simple slogan “if in doubt, leave it out”, meaning anything you hesitate about sharing with your followers, just don’t.

What really stood out is that none of the journalists present had a condescending view of their followers on Twitter. They saw it as a communication tool and a method of collaboration and research. One of the more frequent discussions in social media is whether Twitter will eventually kill and replace Facebook but I think the last few months have shown that both are completely different entities capable of co-existing without tearing a hole in the space-time continuum. Facebook is still much more personal and private means of communication for the vast majority of us (and thus still rather ethically grey for journalists who still trawl Facebook for the digital deathknock) but Twitter is a much more open community for sharing information.

Now that the world gotten over the initial Twitter hype, Twitter still isn’t voxpopping; it’s a conversation everyone is in on.

An open letter to the Sydney Morning Herald

Hi there Mr Editor,

Long time reader, first time writer. There’s just been something plaguing my thoughts for quite a while and every day it seems to get worse.

I’m an avid reader of blogs such as Mashable and TechCruch, and I subscribe to them via RSS using Google Reader. It is always a source of amusement seeing Asher Moses, the SMH’s technology reporter, lift stories I read up to four days ago from various tech blogs and report them almost verbatim in his column.

I would consider this rather redundant reporting, and one of my colleagues suggested, and I agreed, that your paper would be much better served if Asher’s column space was converted into an RSS reader (such as Google Reader) subscribed to all the websites Mr Moses lifts his articles from. For starters, it would be much more cost effective for Fairfax in these tough economic times, and your readers would also benefit by not getting news that is usually at least a day old from blogs!

Please let me know if you need assistance in setting this up, and I will more than happily show you how to do it.

It’s a win-win situation!

Sincerely,

Josh.

Richard Wilkins – International Butt of the Joke

Following the death of Michael Jackson on Friday, the media was in a frenzy that had not been seen before. Twitter went down, Google thought they were under attack and traditional media struggled to keep up.

The most-widely replayed media stuff-up was the reporting that actor Jeff Goldblum had fell to his death while filming in New Zealand.

It’s an old nugget that had been used before but it got a re-run on Twitter and before we knew it, the Today Show’s increasingly leather wallet-looking Richard Wilkins was reporting it as though the NZ police had confirmed it. They didn’t check the facts and it wasn’t until a viewer emailed the show that they dismissed it as a hoax.

Today on The Colbert Report, Jeff Goldblum responds to Wilkins ever-exaggerated reports of his so-called demise.

The Colbert Report Mon – Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c
Jeff Goldblum Will Be Missed
www.colbertnation.com
Colbert Report Full Episodes Political Humor Jeff Goldblum

Iran = vindication for Bush, really

I can’t say anything about Iran that hasn’t been said by many others. I’ve been watching with horror at the endless YouTube coverage and Twitter updates of those right in the thick of it. Now things have died down a little, mostly due to threats of violence against those who would protest, the ideologues come out to try to get their version of history out there.

Such as Janet Albrechtsen, who today somehow manages to use the situation in Iran to try to re-write history in favour of her idol George W Bush.

Could it be that history will now record George W. Bush more kindly than his critics would prefer? What is happening in Iran cannot be separated from what has happened in Iraq. This year, during provincial elections in Iraq, Iraqis came to polling booths in their millions to vote, by an overwhelming margin, for national, secularist parties. Iraqi security forces – not coalition troops – ensured Iraqis could vote safely and securely. There were no suicide bombers endangering polling stations. People turned up with their children to cast their vote.

In an almost complete and unrelated tangent, ignoring the on-going and seemingly never ending problems in Iraq, Albrechtsen claims that by comparing the situation in Iran – where an estimated 20 people have been killed in protests – to an Iraqi election held rather peacefully amidst a near 100,000 documented deaths since the invasion, Bush will be vindicated.

Janet is right, Australian students should be taught about the history of democracy; just not her version of it.

Apologies for the break in transmission

Due to being much busier than expected over the past few months, I haven’t had as much time to devote to this website as I wanted. This should change from next week, so expect much more content.

In the meantime, please enjoy my rather amateur attempt at a soundslide I completed for a recent assignment. It’s just a small example of the homophobia rife on Sydney’s commercial talkback radio stations around the time of Mardi Gras.

Facebook is Ruining Journalism

facebook

Whether it is the latest celebrity gossip, candid shots or getting pictures of the latest car crash victim, journalists in newsrooms around the world are now scouring social networking sites for their stories. But questions are being raised about whether the increasingly standard practice of Facebook journalism is an ethical one.

Facebook places the responsibility for privacy firmly on their users by allowing users to determine who can see what information they list on their profile. Facebook’s privacy policy warns users to be aware of what information they post on Facebook as “this information may become publicly available”.

While most of the general public may rely on their relative privacy through obscurity, if they’re thrust into the public spotlight that information is there for the journalists’ taking.

Read more…

Horrordays and the Media

As the Christmas Cheer begins to roll in and all your regular media commentators depart leaving the Leila McKinnons and the Samantha Armytages of the world to take over, and stories about the best christmas lights or the post-Christmas sales start to dominate, the media news cycle tends to die. A lot.

Excepting a major disaster, like a tsunami, now is about the time that the stories that wouldn’t really get a run seem to dominate the news.

Read more…

Today Tonight, dedicated investigative journalists

Last Thursday night, TT tried to show up Foxtel by giving this dodgy guy an airing who is trying to sell free software on his dodgy website. The software allows you to view streaming cable channels but the software he’s pushing is software that is normally freely available, and was using TT to push his stuff. Just watch the video, the guy looks uber dodgy.

Not just that, Peter Blasina is about the most woefully incompetant IT ‘guru’ around. He completely failed to pick up on what was wrong with the story. I think his bright shirt must have blinded his eyes to how dodgy this guy really is. But he can use an escalator and his shiny 3G phone at the same time! Give that man airtime!!

Read more…